THE STORY IN BRIEF
  • Only one preserved specimen of the Lānaʻi hookbill is known.
  • Researchers identified the specimen as female and found evidence of past interbreeding.
  • The wider analysis included living birds, extinct species and fossils.
MAKE TIME FOR A GOOD READ
Inside this story 2 perspectives

At the Bishop Museum in Honolulu, one bird holds nearly all the physical evidence researchers have of the Lānaʻi hookbill. The Hawaiian honeycreeper is extinct. Only a single specimen is known to survive in a collection. For years, scientists trying to place the bird among its relatives had to contend with the condition of its genetic material as well as a simple limit on their work. There would never be a second individual against which to check its story.

In an interview broadcast on 20 August, Smithsonian researchers Michael Campana and Robert Fleischer described to Hawaiʻi Public Radio what this particular specimen could finally tell them. They identified it as female and found evidence that its lineage had interbred with another honeycreeper, the ʻōʻū. The finding came from a larger international study, published earlier this month, that examined surviving and extinct members of the Hawaiian group.

An island with room for new relatives

Hawaiian honeycreepers are an unusually rich example of how many species can emerge from one ancestor. More than sixty species evolved on the islands. Seventeen survive. Researchers examined those living species alongside eighteen that had survived at least until Europeans arrived in 1778 and two others represented by fossils. The much larger historical group gives scientists a way to see branches missing from a diagram drawn only from modern birds.

Most of the diversification identified by the researchers took place roughly 2.5 million to 3.5 million years ago, around the time Oʻahu formed. The team suggested that new habitats could have provided room for distinct populations to develop. In that account, the geography offers a possible explanation for the timing. The timing alone cannot show which stretch of habitat a particular bird occupied.

What a museum gets to keep

The hookbill adds a further complication to a family tree. A typical drawing shows a branch splitting in two and the descendants following separate lines. Evidence of interbreeding means genetic material moved between lineages after they diverged. A drawing that also connects those branches tells a more accurate story. It gives the single specimen in Honolulu something to say about birds beyond its own species.

There are limits to what any collection can rescue. One female cannot show the full range of differences within a vanished population. A museum can, however, keep evidence available for a question that no one could answer when the specimen arrived. That changes the calculation around storage and care. For the hookbill, the value of maintaining a bird over generations includes both the questions people have already asked it and those a future curator might be the first to recognise.

BB
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Beyond Business Editors

Editorial desk

Beyond Business connects global developments with the decisions, ambitions and everyday lives of its readers. Our editorial desk explores the stories shaping our world.

More from this author
Keep the perspective.