- The planet orbits a small red star roughly every three days.
- Water, methane, carbon dioxide and ammonia left signatures as starlight passed through its atmosphere.
- Longer-wavelength observations could test whether clouds explain the unexpectedly low inferred temperature.
Inside this story 2 perspectives
HATS-6 b takes roughly three days to circle its star. Even with a small, relatively cool red star providing the light, that sounds like an unlikely address for a planet cooler than astronomers expected. Yet that is what a University of Maryland team found when it used the James Webb Space Telescope to examine the gas around this distant world. Another result gives the puzzle an unusually good chemical clue. The team found ammonia, a molecule that has rarely been detected by this particular method outside our solar system.
The research, published in The Astronomical Journal on 8 September and reported by Phys.org on 25 September, concerns a planet about 500 light-years away. It is roughly the size of Jupiter. Its host, an M dwarf, is far smaller than our sun. Astronomers would like to know how a small star and the disk of material surrounding it managed to produce such a large companion.
What the starlight carried
When HATS-6 b crosses in front of its star from our point of view, some starlight passes through the planet’s atmosphere on its way to the telescope. Molecules absorb particular wavelengths. Reading the resulting pattern, a technique called transmission spectroscopy, allowed the Maryland-led team to identify water, carbon dioxide, methane and ammonia. Lead author Giannina Guzmán Caloca and colleagues describe the ammonia result as only the second detection of the molecule on a distant planet using this technique.
Cooler gas giants may harbour more ammonia than very hot ones. Finding the molecule therefore gives the team a way to compare atmospheres belonging to planets around different kinds of stars. HATS-6 b is one of seven targets in a Webb programme examining giant planets around M dwarfs. A recurring chemical pattern across several of them would carry different weight from an unusual result on one.
Two temperatures and a cloud hypothesis
One familiar estimate puts HATS-6 b near 800 degrees Fahrenheit. It assumes that the planet absorbs all the incoming starlight and distributes that heat evenly. Early analyses of the spectrum returned a value closer to 250 degrees Fahrenheit. Neither figure comes from placing a thermometer in the atmosphere. Each depends on how researchers interpret what happens to the star’s light.
A layer of reflective clouds or haze might send enough light back into space to help explain a cooler atmosphere. The observations do not establish that this is happening. The team points to observations at longer wavelengths as a way of testing that account and investigating other features in the spectrum. Temperature also affects the chemical interpretation, so resolving the discrepancy would do more than settle what number to print in a catalogue. It would help establish how confidently astronomers can infer what surrounds a giant planet when their only sample is the light that has passed through it.



