THE STORY IN BRIEF
  • India and the five SACU members signed terms of reference on 12 August.
  • Goods, rules of origin, customs procedures and sanitary measures are on the negotiating agenda.
  • The signature opens negotiations. It does not establish new rates or a start date for concessions.
MAKE TIME FOR A GOOD READ
Inside this story 2 perspectives

A manufacturer in Lesotho could make a garment for an Indian buyer using cloth bought from another country. Where the garment was sewn might be easy to establish. Whether it would count as originating in Southern Africa for a preferential tariff is a different question, and it is one the two sides have yet to settle.

On 12 August, India and the Southern African Customs Union signed terms of reference in New Delhi for talks on a preferential trade agreement. The customs union comprises Botswana, Eswatini, Lesotho, Namibia and South Africa. The signature gives negotiations a framework across eight chapters. It leaves the eventual product list, concessions and implementation dates to be agreed.

What a buyer would have to prove

Rules of origin describe how a product qualifies for the treatment reserved for a trading partner. They matter most when the supply chain does not fit neatly inside one country. Clothing can be designed in one place, cut and sewn in another, and assembled from materials bought elsewhere. A rule might look at the processing that took place or the share of value added. No such test for the hypothetical garment was announced at the signing.

This part of the talks matters on both sides of the Indian Ocean. An Indian engineering firm sending machinery to southern Africa may use components from several countries. A southern African processor selling into India may bring in packaging or intermediate materials. If either supplier has to trace an input, the cost of doing so belongs in the commercial calculation alongside the proposed saving. A small order can lose its advantage if the paperwork costs almost as much as the duty avoided.

A tariff schedule is only one document

Customs procedures and sanitary and phytosanitary measures are also on the agenda. A food exporter has reason to watch both. The importer needs to establish the applicable rate, while the product may also have to meet plant or animal health conditions. A concession could improve the arithmetic on a consignment without answering whether it can enter the destination market in the first place.

India’s commerce minister Piyush Goyal identified medicines, machinery, textiles and agricultural processing among areas with commercial possibilities. His call to move quickly sets out an ambition. An exporter deciding what price to put on an invoice still needs an agreed text, effective date and rules applicable to the actual item.

There is useful work to do while officials negotiate. A manufacturer can identify the product it sells, where its inputs come from and what evidence it already keeps. That exercise would make a future proposal easier to test. It can also reveal when a concession that looks attractive at a national level would in practice be most usable by a much smaller group of firms.

BB
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Beyond Business Editors

Editorial desk

Beyond Business connects global developments with the decisions, ambitions and everyday lives of its readers. Our editorial desk explores the stories shaping our world.

More from this author
Keep the perspective.