- The Edinburgh International Festival commissioned the collaboration for Usher Hall.
- Wang and Wynton Marsalis selected music associated with pianists including Thelonious Monk and Art Tatum.
- The programme calls on specially prepared arrangements for soloist and orchestra.
Inside this story 2 perspectives
A solo pianist has two hands with which to suggest an entire band. Put an actual band behind the same player and an arranger faces a deceptively difficult question. Which parts of the piano music should the orchestra take, and which depend on a single musician playing several things at once? Edinburgh has given that question a pianist, a jazz orchestra and two performances in which to hear possible answers.
The Edinburgh International Festival commissioned Yuja Wang and the Jazz at Lincoln Center Orchestra with Wynton Marsalis to appear at Usher Hall on 12 August. Wang and Marsalis selected the pieces together. The advertised programme draws on the work of several pianists, and the music has been specially arranged for the collaboration. It gives the audience a way into the evening beyond the familiar pairing of a classical soloist with a jazz ensemble.
Listen for who keeps the tune
Among the selections Marsalis highlighted are Thelonious Monk’s Monk’s Mood, Dave Brubeck’s Blue Rondo à la Turk and Art Tatum’s rendition of Tiger Rag. The list also invokes Oscar Peterson, Bill Evans and Erroll Garner. A listener need not know all six musicians in advance. Pick one melody and follow it as the performance moves between the pianist and the rest of the group.
That exercise makes the arranger’s decisions audible. A line can be clear when heard alone on a piano and hard to pick out once several instruments enter in the same register. Giving a phrase to a reed or brass instrument can change where the ear goes, even when its notes remain recognisable. Leaving a band silent for a moment can also be an arrangement choice. It allows a single piano accent or a pause to do the work that a fuller sound might otherwise obscure.
The rhythm section adds another possibility. A pianist playing alone may carry melody, bass and time across two hands. In an ensemble a bassist can take over the bottom line while a drummer gives a repeated figure its shape. The piano can then answer a phrase, interrupt it or leave space for somebody else. These are decisions to listen for at Usher Hall, rather than predictions about how a particular passage will sound.
What a festival can commission
A concert of recognisable tunes can still require substantial new work. A festival that commissions arrangements makes it possible for musicians to ask questions that a standard touring set may already have answered. The two advertised performances, at 6pm and 9pm, share a programme. The interesting comparison for listeners is less about a change of repertoire than about which musical voice they find themselves following when a familiar pianist has an entire orchestra to answer.



