THE STORY IN BRIEF
  • 54% of respondents in EY-Parthenon’s June wave reported no new savings.
  • Achieve’s separate survey focused on adults with an active credit account.
  • The New York Fed measured expectations, including the perceived risk of missing a payment.
MAKE TIME FOR A GOOD READ
Inside this story 2 perspectives

A household can buy the same groceries and pay the same rent two months running, yet end the second month in a weaker position. The clue may be in the deposit it did not make into savings, or the credit card balance carried a little longer. New US survey results released on 10 August illustrate why spending alone is an incomplete guide to how comfortably households are living.

EY-Parthenon asked 1,509 US consumers about their experience in June. Some 54% said they had saved no money that month. Roughly one in five households reported spending more than their income. Those answers describe different things. A household that has previously accumulated savings can go a month without adding to them. A family whose expenses exceed income can close the gap by drawing on that balance or by taking on debt.

A purchase that can wait

Asked where there was still room to economise, 72% of EY respondents identified discretionary areas such as dining, clothing or personal care. The answer offers a retailer insight into the purchases its customers consider flexible. It does not establish that all of those customers have already stopped eating out or buying clothes. There is a difference between identifying a possible saving and choosing to make it.

Another survey released the same day shows the question from a borrower’s perspective. In June, financial services company Achieve surveyed 2,000 US adults who had an active account in at least one specified credit category. Of those respondents, 56% said it would take more than six months to repay all their short-term unsecured debt. Reading that as a share of every US household would miss a central feature of the research: people without a qualifying credit account were outside the sample.

Paying today and worrying about tomorrow

The New York Fed offers a third measure. Its July survey asked household heads to estimate their own chances of missing a minimum debt payment during the next three months. The average answer rose to 12%, even as people on balance became less pessimistic about their household finances. That number describes a perceived probability. It is different from a recorded share of accounts in arrears.

Together the three studies give a more precise reading of financial pressure without requiring their percentages to match. One asks what a broad group of consumers did in June. Another asks current credit users how long repayment would take. The third asks how households judge a risk ahead. A shopper can plausibly report steady spending, a longer repayment horizon and a hope that conditions will improve, all at once. The purchase visible at the till is only the first part of that story.

BB
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Beyond Business Editors

Editorial desk

Beyond Business connects global developments with the decisions, ambitions and everyday lives of its readers. Our editorial desk explores the stories shaping our world.

More from this author
Keep the perspective.