THE STORY IN BRIEF
  • The research analysed 12,418 real shopping sessions.
  • Higher spending was associated with trolley use in this setting.
  • List uploaders and other frequent screen users showed distinct patterns.
MAKE TIME FOR A GOOD READ
Inside this story 2 perspectives

A screen attached to a supermarket trolley can help a shopper find an unfamiliar item, follow a list or discover a product the store recommends. It can also tell a retailer something about how people shop. In a German supermarket study, shoppers who engaged with smart trolleys spent an average of 32% more than the comparison group. The figure makes an appealing promise to a retailer. The design of the study makes it a question worth testing.

The research, featured in an August 12 release from City St George’s, University of London, analysed 12,418 shopping sessions over a month. It looked at the number of items bought, the value of the basket and the time spent in the shop. It also examined how people used different functions. The researchers describe this as a descriptive analysis of field data. Customers made their own choices about using the technology.

The weekly shop is already different

Imagine a shopper who comes in on Saturday with a long list and time to try the digital screen. Someone else hurries in on a weekday evening for a single forgotten ingredient. They might have spent different amounts with identical trolleys. Comparing their receipts after one uses a screen cannot separate the effect of the device from the reason each person came through the door.

That concern is especially relevant when a business considers the next step. A 32% difference in the observed baskets is not a forecast of a 32% sales increase across a supermarket that buys the equipment. Existing customers who already intend to spend more might prefer the devices. A screen might also change purchasing decisions after the trip begins. Both mechanisms could operate together.

There are clues in the detailed results. Shoppers who uploaded a list tended to have higher-value but smaller baskets and shorter visits. People interacting with the screen particularly frequently tended to stay longer and buy more items, without a corresponding increase in total spending. The same equipment supported at least two very different patterns. A customer seeking an efficient route through a shop need not behave like someone interested in browsing recommendations.

What would count as a successful trial?

For a grocer the answer depends on the job it has given the trolley. A feature intended to help people find products might be judged on search time or the number of items a shopper gives up looking for. A recommendation tool raises a different question about additional purchases, margin and whether customers welcome the suggestions. Treating time spent in the store as a success in every case would penalise the efficient trip the list uploader may have wanted.

A stronger test of the spending claim would make the choice of comparison less dependent on people’s initial enthusiasm for the device. Until then, the German study offers something more specific than a promise of sales growth. It shows why the shopping list, the time of day and the receipt belong in the same conversation.

BB
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Beyond Business Editors

Editorial desk

Beyond Business connects global developments with the decisions, ambitions and everyday lives of its readers. Our editorial desk explores the stories shaping our world.

More from this author
Keep the perspective.