THE STORY IN BRIEF
  • Researchers studied 3.6 million message threads in one large academic health system.
  • The intended clinician and another member of the care team were counted separately.
  • The study found associations between writing style and response patterns. It did not test whether changing how a patient writes improves care.
MAKE TIME FOR A GOOD READ
Inside this story 2 perspectives

Sending a message to a named clinician through a patient portal can feel like sending an email to a particular person. Inside a clinic, the message may first reach a team member who has to decide who should respond. In a US study published on 24 August, that distinction between the addressee and the eventual respondent turned out to be important.

Researchers examined more than 3.6 million medical-advice message threads sent by 511,020 adult patients to primary-care clinicians at one large academic health system. They studied messages initiated from 2021 to 2023. They measured both whether anyone on the care team responded and whether the person to whom the message was originally addressed replied. The second outcome revealed differences that an overall count of answers could obscure.

When the greeting becomes part of the evidence

Black patients had a response rate from the intended clinician 3.7 percentage points lower than White patients in the study. The research team analysed characteristics of the messages, including length, formality and the way a writer opened a note. It also examined the subject matter. What patients were asking about mattered to whether a clinician responded, but explained little of the observed gap between these groups.

In the researchers’ statistical analysis, differences in writing style accounted for about 48% of that particular gap. It would be a mistake to promise a patient that a more formal greeting increases the likelihood of a clinically appropriate response. The researchers analysed existing records. They did not randomly ask patients to use different styles, then compare the results. Other differences among patients, their circumstances and the way a practice organises its work may also matter.

What a clinic can find out

Receiving a reply from a nurse or another team member can be exactly right for a particular request. The identity of the person who replies does not, by itself, tell a reader whether the advice was helpful, whether an issue was resolved on the phone or whether a patient received good care. The study raises a narrower question about consistency: when two people need much the same thing, does the way they phrase the request affect whose attention it receives?

A practice examining its own inbox could compare similar requests and trace what happens after the first review. A staff member may be able to resolve a repeat administrative question quickly or identify a need to direct a clinical concern to a colleague. Looking at how often that process ends in a clear response, and whether that varies across groups, could reveal something that a raw reply count misses.

For patients, writing to a clinic should not require mastering an unwritten literary style. A clearer statement from the practice about who reads messages, who may reply and how to follow up would put some of the responsibility back where the information sits.

BB
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Beyond Business Editors

Editorial desk

Beyond Business connects global developments with the decisions, ambitions and everyday lives of its readers. Our editorial desk explores the stories shaping our world.

More from this author
Keep the perspective.