THE STORY IN BRIEF
  • Researchers compared what givers expected with what recipients reported.
  • The Chicago field experiment invited people to give away a hot drink.
  • The results describe averages in specific settings, leaving room for personal preferences.
MAKE TIME FOR A GOOD READ
Inside this story 2 perspectives

At Maggie Daley Park in Chicago, 84 people faced a modest choice. They could keep a cup of hot chocolate or have it given to a stranger. Seventy-five chose to give it away. The researchers then asked a question more interesting than whether it was pleasant to get a free drink. How close could the person who gave it get to guessing how the recipient would feel?

World Kindness Day, observed on 13 November, puts an annual date against an ordinary human hesitation. A person considers a small gesture and wonders whether it will matter enough to justify interrupting somebody else’s day. Research by Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley, first published online in 2022, suggests one reason that judgement can be off. People may correctly anticipate that a recipient will appreciate the gesture and still underestimate by how much.

What the giver could not taste

In the Chicago experiment a research assistant took the drink to the recipient and explained that another participant had chosen to give it to them. The recipients reported how they felt. The givers separately estimated those reactions. On average, the people receiving the drinks rated their experience more positively than those who supplied them had predicted. The result was part of a series of studies using field and laboratory settings.

It is possible to put a straightforward value on the drink. There is a price on the menu and a cold day makes a hot drink useful. There is another part of the experience that is harder for its giver to price. A stranger who could have kept something decided to pass it on. The researchers’ work points to the warmth recipients read into that decision. From the giver’s side of the counter, it can be easier to think about the modest size of the gift.

Why a small gesture still needs judgement

The study describes averages among particular participants in a particular setting. A colleague concentrating on a deadline may prefer to be left alone. Someone who declines a drink may already have one or may simply dislike chocolate. A considerate offer leaves its recipient enough room to decline without having to put the giver at ease. There are other ways to help, including doing a useful piece of shared work without adding to another person’s list of obligations.

That qualification still leaves room for a change of habit. Think of a colleague who once took an extra five minutes to show you how something was done. A brief note about the difference it made gives them a piece of information they could not have guessed from their own side of the exchange. Like the cup in the park, the material cost is small. Only the person receiving it knows the rest of its value.

BB
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Beyond Business Editors

Editorial desk

Beyond Business connects global developments with the decisions, ambitions and everyday lives of its readers. Our editorial desk explores the stories shaping our world.

More from this author
Keep the perspective.