- A net 27% of banks reported weaker demand for house-purchase loans in the third quarter.
- The survey balance for mortgage approval standards was zero, while agreed contract terms tightened.
- Banks identified higher interest rates as the main reason for weaker demand, followed by confidence and housing market prospects.
Inside this story 2 perspectives
Can it get harder to afford a mortgage without banks raising the bar for approving one? The European Central Bank’s October lending survey offers an example. Banks reported broadly unchanged internal approval standards for house-purchase loans in the third quarter, but a pronounced decline in demand. Higher interest rates were the main reason banks gave for that decline.
The net balance of lenders reporting a drop in mortgage demand was 27%. In the previous three months it had been 15%, and the decline was greater than the banks had expected. These figures describe a survey of banks. They do not mean that the number of applications or the euro value of mortgages issued fell by 27%. Each measure would require data about loans themselves, rather than a count of lenders reporting a direction of change.
Three decisions sit behind one mortgage
A household first decides whether to seek a loan. It can change its mind about buying a home when monthly repayments look high against income, even before speaking to a bank. The lender then applies its approval criteria. If borrower and bank proceed, the contract specifies the actual terms, including the interest rate and other conditions. A change at any one of these stages can affect the result.
In the survey, the net balance for tightening housing-loan approval standards was zero. A zero balance can arise when tightening at some institutions is offset by easing at others or when rules generally stay put. Across lending categories banks nevertheless reported tighter terms on the contracts they agreed, mainly through interest rates. For households weighing a purchase, an unchanged lending rule can coexist with an unattractive monthly payment.
What the survey can tell an applicant
Consumer borrowing showed a different pattern. A net 14% of banks reported tighter rules for consumer credit and other lending to households. Demand in that category fell only slightly on balance. The contrast makes it risky to take a general report about borrowing conditions and apply it to a mortgage, a personal loan and a credit-card balance equally. Banks treat them as different products, and potential customers use them for different purposes.
Lenders also cited weaker consumer confidence and less favourable housing market prospects as factors behind mortgage demand. These are the banks’ assessments of the quarter, rather than interviews with every family that postponed a move. For an individual considering a loan, the uncertainty is best narrowed through the proposed interest rate, payment schedule and the household’s own income. For policymakers, the survey answers a broader question. In the third quarter, lenders saw a substantial retreat in demand even without a net tightening of mortgage approval rules.



